Showing posts with label Compulsory Voting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Compulsory Voting. Show all posts

Right to cast "Negative Vote"

11 comments

Today morning after reading my post on compulsory voting, my friend Ajai was asking me about right to caste a negative vote. He was saying, he has never felt anyone except Dr.Shashi Tharoor deserved his vote. I am pretty sure many others would be feeling the same as Ajai. Often we may not find any candidate who are eligible to get our vote but still we will have to vote for someone or we will have to abstain from voting. In the latter case we are not exercising a valuable right; rather we are forced not to exercise it.
Do we have a right o caste to a negative vote?? As of now the answer is no.
In the voting using the conventional ballot paper and ballot boxes, an elector can drop the ballot paper without marking his vote against any of the candidates, if he chooses so. However, in the voting using the Electronic Voting Machines, such a facility is not available to the voter. Although, Rule 49 O of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 provides that an elector may refuse to vote after he has been identified and necessary entries made in the Register of Electors and the marked copy of the electoral roll, the secrecy of voting is not protected herein as much as the polling officials and the polling agents in the polling station get to know about the decision of such a voter.
The Election Commission has recommended in its report on "Electoral Reforms" that the law should be amended to specifically provide for negative / neutral voting. For this purpose, Rules 22 and 49B of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 may be suitably amended adding a proviso that in the ballot paper and the particulars on the ballot unit, in the column relating to names of candidates, after the entry relating to the last candidate, there shall be a column “None of the above”, to enable a voter to reject all the candidates, if he chooses so. Such a proposal was earlier also made by the Commission in 2001.
A petition filed by the NGO People’s Union for Civil Liberties seeking such a provision filed at the time of the recent general elections is pending before the Hon’b'le Supreme Court now. The government in this case has informed the Supreme Court that Indian citizens have no "statutory right to refrain from voting". The case which initially came up before a two judge bench has been referred to a larger bench. A two-judge bench of Justice B N Aggrawal (As His Lordship then was) and Justice G S Singhvi felt that the issue needed to be adjudicated by a larger bench as there were certain "doubts" over the interpretation of the ruling passed by a Constitution Bench in the Kuldip Nayar vs Union of India case relating to a voter's right. They opined: "The opening line of para 362 tends to create a doubt whether the right of a voter to exercise his choice for the candidate is a necessary concomitant of the voter's freedom of expression guaranteed under Article 19 (1)(a) (freedom of expression and speech). Therefore, this issue needs a clear exposition of law by a larger bench. "


The ball is now in the Apex Court's court. Lets hope the Apex Court will recognize the right of a voter to cast negative vote.

THE COMPULSORY VOTING BILL, 2009

0 comments

Well friends THE COMPULSORY VOTING BILL, 2009 was introduced by SHRI J.P. AGARWAL, M.P. in the Lok Sabha to provide for compulsory voting by the electorate in the country and for matters connected therewith.
Section 2 says:
"It shall be compulsory for every voter who is eligible to vote at an election to
exercise his right to vote when called for by the Election Commission:
Provided that a voter may be exempted from exercising his right to vote—
(a) if he is physically incapacitated from an illness of a serious nature and
produces a medical certificate from a registered medical practitioner certifying such
incapacity; or
(b) if the Election Commission or such other authority as may be empowered by
the Election Commission, on receipt of a request either before or after the poll, from the
voter, is satisfied that there are genuine and bona fide grounds for such exemption."

Well this provision makes voting compulsory and further section 8 lays down the punishment in case of failure to vote. It says:

"Any person, who fails to cast his vote shall be liable to—
(i) A fine of rupees five hundred, or
(ii) two day’s imprisonment, or
(iii) forfeiture of his ration card;
(iv) be rendered ineligible for contesting any election for a period of ten years
from the date of his conviction;
(v) be ineligible for allotment of a plot or a house in a Government owned
organisation;
(vi) be ineligible to get loan of any kind from any financial institution owned by
the Government;
(vii) be ineligible for entitlement to any welfare scheme announced by the
Government from time to time:

Provided that if such person is an employee of the Union Government or the State
Government or the Union territory administration or any public sector undertaking owned or controlled by Union Government or the State Government or the Union territory administration,
such person shall also be punished with—
(a) forfeiture of ten days' salary; and
(b) delay in promotion for a period of two years."

Further section 9 provides certain incentives to persons who has caste their vote despite of their illness or physical incapicity. It says:

"Any person who, despite his illness or physical incapacity has exercised his right to
vote at an election or any person who has exercised his right to vote at all elections held
during a period of fifteen years preceding the commencement of this Act without any break
shall be—
(i) given preference in jobs in the services under the Central Government; and
(ii) given preference in admission to the institutions of higher education."

I would also like to draw your attention to THE CONSTITUTION (AMENDMENT) BILL, 2009 introduced by SHRI K.C. SINGH BABA, M.P. The bill seeks to insert clause (k) in Article 51A. Section 2 of the amendment Act is as follows:

"In article 51A of the Constitution, after clause (k), the following clause shall be
added, namely:—
“(l) to cast vote at elections to the House of the People, Legislative
Assemblies of States and local bodies.”.

Well both these bills are on the same path, one bill makes voting compulsory whereas the other makes it a fundamental duty to cast vote. There is no argument as to the fact that the number of voters have gone down much over the years; everyone agrees on this. Well isn't this because people have lost faith in the system? Is our democracy a failure?? Section 3 of the COMPULSORY VOTING BILL mandates that election commission should give adequate protection and safety to all citizens who come to polling booths to cast their votes. Are our citizens afraid to come to the booths?? In the recent elections to parliament, a present cabinet minister, was first declared to have lost the elections but later it was changed and he was declared as the winner in the elections. Are the hands of the election commission clean?? These are all questions which are difficult to answer.

Will be back with more inputs soon !!!

NB: Full text of both the bills are available at www.answeringlaw.com

Powered by Blogger.

All Rights Reserved

Unless specified to the contrary, the contents of this blog and these pages are protected by copyright and no part of them may be reproduced in any form or used in any other way except with the Blog Administrator's prior written permission or in accordance with the next term set out below. You may print off or download the visible text on the site for personal non-commercial purposes but it may not be used for any other purpose.